Grateful Dead - Winterland 1973Â The Complete Recordings (11/9-11/73 + Cincinatti Gardens 12/4/73 bonus disc)
There was something of a debacle involved when the Grateful Dead released the Fillmore 1969 box set. As a limited edition of 10,000 copies the box became an instant collectors item and now goes for around $1,000 on e-bay. I was very lucky when a small window opened for cancellations and I managed to grab one, but I felt for anyone interested who didn’t, particularly as that series of shows is among the best in the Grateful Dead’s catalog, hell I’d say it’s one of the best live series of shows by anyone.
However, Rhino seems to have fixed the issue for the next box set, covering three gigs at Winterland in later 1973. This time it doesn’t appear to be a limited edition and potential customers had plenty of time to decide and still get the bonus disc. And not only that but no expenses were spared for the presentation, quite simply one of the most amazing box sets ever devised, with a gorgeous outer box with an eye in rose in skull wreathed in an aura of fire and casting blue and green wavy lines all over the rest of the outer box. Inside, three 3 CD fold out booklets, all of which open up as one third of the box’s essential artwork (on the inside), including a similar skull insignia but surrounded by members of the crowd, all ranging from mythical to real figures. Also a “Good Ol’ Grateful Dead button, a sizable booklet with new liner notes and a repro of the original 1973 mail out announcing the concerts. And if you were early a CD in slip case of the highlights from the Cincinatti Gardens show a little later in the year.
This is one of the band’s strongest Winterland runs. I suppose I go against the conventional opinion in thinking the Dead were generally not at their best at this venue, but in this case, at least for the 10th and 11th gigs, I wouldn’t have good evidence for my opinion. The 9th, like many first shows of a run, is tentative for the most part, an average first set and a second set that starts to promise for the rest of the series with the Weather Report Suite>Let It Grow> Eyes>China Doll suite. The band would play Weather Report Suite all three nights, each one, perhaps, an incremental improvement.
The 10th is definitely one of those special nights and in particular the sandwich suite at the head of set 2, only played a few times by the Dead, is spectacular: Playin>Uncle John>Morning Dew>Uncle John>Playin. The band’s digging its feet in and even the first set has a number of gems, including a beautiful Tennesee Jed and Brokedown Palace. There was a real fragile beauty about the guitarwork around that time, perhaps the band’s fusion influence at the time or maybe Weir’s ascendance in his own right. Much of the playing is interactive, yet delicate and most importantly the group seems to lack all self consciousness.
The 11th is nearly as good, after all it’s the set of the week with a rather fantastic and at times, very abstract Dark Star, which benefits from all the interplay and near psychic integration involved. This was the only show I was familiar with beforehand and found it benefitted from the mastering work. Or at least it seemed a bit more energetic than I had remembered. It’s also one of their rare shows without a Playin’ in the Band, but you’d barely miss it.
The bonus disc captures most of the relevant and important material from the 12/4 Cincinatti Gardens gig, including the relatively short second set in its entirety. To my ears while there are some nice moments like in Truckin’>Stella Blue, for the most part the slightly lesser quality and relative mundanity of the playing here make this less notable than its attached box set, but it does seem like in the end one disc would be all you need from the show, at least given the rest of the set list.
Near pefection really, a great stint from one of the band’s best years housed in fantastic packaging. If only the live material of every band had this sort of attention. Right now I’m kind of wondering why I haven’t pulled it out again!